I really need some sincere advice..?

wow long. i think you were right asking him if anything was going on with him and dominic. but he totally started to dig himself a hole when he said he didnt know who to choose. maybe he was playing hard to get? by the way it looks to be working out, maybe he's not everything you thought he was. history does repeat itself, and it looks as though you're repeating. maybe you wont talk for a while, then strike up a conversation and start over again; get another chance. personally, i think ya'll need to sit down and talk about everything that you've just said.